Cream Cheese Grilled Cheese

Cream Cheese Grilled Cheese

I must first say Happy New Year to everyone. Hopefully you were able to celebrate New Year’s Eve with friends and family in a great environment. Now onto the newest grilled cheese creation featuring cream cheese. This sandwich was inspired by Grilled Cheese Social‘s “Team Cream” post/grilled cheese. I had hoped to follow the recipe exactly, but since this grilled cheese was a last minute decision, we arrived at Whole Foods late and all the bagels were gone. Instead, I went with “seeduction bread,” which is quickly becoming one of my favorite types of bread.


  • Cream Cheese w/Thyme & Chives
  • Heirloom Tomatoes
  • Seeduction Bread

Cream Cheese Grilled Cheese: Cream Cheese

the cheese: cream cheese

Cream cheese is such a common cheese but I never knew, until now, how it was invented.

There are French references to cream cheese as early as 1651. References to cream cheese in England start from at least 1754, and recipes follow soon after, particularly from Lincolnshire and the southwest of England.

According to the American food processing company Kraft Foods, the first American cream cheese was made in New York in 1872 by American dairyman William Lawrence. In 1880, ‘Philadelphia’ was adopted as the brand name, after the city that was considered at the time to be the home of top quality food.

The technique is known to have been in use in Normandy since the 1850s, producing cheeses with higher fat content than the US model, and Philadelphia cream cheese has been suggested as a substitute when petit suisse is not available.

Philadelphia is used by some as a generic term for cream cheese, and in Spanish it is translated as queso Filadelfia or “queso crema.” (Wikipedia)

Also, who knew that USDA required that cream cheese “contain at least 33% fat and no more than 55% water,¬†although there are low-fat and nonfat varieties now on the market.” (

Cream Cheese Grilled Cheese: Heirloom Tomatoes


I was searching Whole Foods for heirloom tomatoes when I found ones that were really ripe and mushy. As these were the basis of the grilled cheese, I was pretty disappointed. Thankfully, I didn’t give up and we asked for help.¬†The nice Whole Foods employee went to the back and brought out a box of much less ripe/mushy heirloom tomatoes to choose from.

Instead of choosing one large tomato, I decided to go with two smaller, different varieties. The dark, more round one had a much different, better taste while the red pepper looking tomato had a very yummy standard tomato flavor.

Cream Cheese Grilled Cheese: Cream Cheese + Thyme + Chives

The recipe calls for fresh thyme and thanks to the recent thawing of snow, we were actually able to harvest some fresh thyme from our garden. In addition to the thyme, I also mixed in chives.

Cream Cheese Grilled Cheese: Seeduction Bread

I previously purchased a seeduction roll from Whole Foods and fell in love the minute I took one bite. The bread is sweet but has a nice texture. After seeing that the bagels were sold out, I was saved when I realized a loaf of seeduction bread was sitting there, waiting for me.

the grilled cheese:

cream cheese grilled cheese: A

Thanks to Grilled Cheese Social and her Team Cream post, I was able to create an awesome grilled cheese. I don’t doubt that the grilled cheese would be amazing on an everything bagel, but it is also pretty darn good on seeduction bread. After finishing the first half of the grilled cheese, I did add more tomatoes to the second half which only made the sandwich better. In order for this type of grilled cheese to be great, the ratio of cream cheese to tomato must be perfect, allowing for multiple textures. You will realize when that happens the minute you take a bite.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.