The Atlantic’s Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese

The Atlantic’s Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese

As you may already know, I receive Google alerts for any mention of the grilled cheese. Sometimes those alerts produce a great article, such as The Atlantic’s The Princess and the Pea, that includes an intriguing recipe like Pea Pesto & Manchego Grilled Cheese. I was honestly surprised to find a grilled cheese recipe in the middle of an article about peas, but I was definitely not disappointed. I am always interested in trying new ingredients, such as pea pesto, as sometimes I feel like I am getting stale with my own thoughts.


  • Homemade Pea Pesto
  • Manchego Cheese
  • Sourdough Ciabatta

The Atlantic's Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese Ingredients: Manchego Cheese

the cheese: manchego

I had previously tried a variety of raw milk manchego in one of my cheese tasting entries and was surprisingly not a fan. I was unsure if it was because I chose the raw milk version or if I simply did not like Manchego in general. However, this recipe called specifically for Manchego so I decided to give it a second chance.

The choice once presented itself again: raw milk or pasteurized. Since we were cooking the cheese and my father has an irregular stomach, we decided to go with the pasteurized version. The cheese monger at Whole Foods said that some of the flavor is lost in the pasteurized version but he did not know if we would notice a difference once the cheese was cooked.

The Atlantic's Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese Ingredients: Manchego Cheese

Manchego cheese is the most important and well-known sheep’s milk cheese in Spain. The shape of this cheese is very characteristic and defined, due to the traditional use of esparto grass molds which imprints a zigzag pattern along the side of the cheese. The small wooden boards used for pressing the cheese also imprints the typical wheat ear pattern on the top and bottom.

Manchego is an aged cheese, from semi-cured to cured, made only with milk from manchega sheep breed, unpasteurized or pasteurized. It is produced through an enzimatic coagulation. The paste is pressed and uncooked. (

This time, however, I did like the Manchego. Maybe my tastes have matured, maybe the pasteurized version does taste different or maybe the melting process helps the taste (in my opinion). I have even continued to use the leftover Manchego in other random places (like scrambled eggs).

The Atlantic's Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese Ingredients: Pine Nuts (Pre-Toast)


I have never really made anything but traditional pesto so I was excited to try a pea pesto.

When I have made a pesto, they have been haphazard with little additional ingredients. However, with this pea pesto, I wanted to make sure I made it correctly with all of the ingredients, including pine nuts. To my surprise, pine nuts are rather pricey but I went ahead and included them.

The Atlantic's Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese Ingredients: Pine Nuts (Post-Toast)

I had to google how to specifically toast pine nuts and might have cooked them just a bit too long but at no point do I believe that affected the taste of the grilled cheese.

Take a dry non-stick pan. Put the pine nuts in it (use no oil) and turn the heat to medium. Shake the pan every 30 seconds and toss the pine nuts. When they are lightly browned, turn the heat off and remove the pinenuts to a plate and leave them to cool. If you leave them in the hot pan they will keep on cooking. (

The Atlantic's Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese Ingredients: Creating Pea Pesto

In the pea pesto are of course peas, pine nuts and your choice of Parmesan cheese. I had some leftover Parmesan from a pasta dinner, but you could of course use some Parmigiano-Reggiano, as the recipe calls for.

The Atlantic's Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese Ingredients: Completed Pea Pesto

The recipe called for this pesto to be placed inside a grilled cheese sandwich, but I wonder how it would taste as a dip with crackers/tortillas. I can’t see why it wouldn’t be good. If I had some leftover I would have definitely tried it but alas, all the pea pesto is gone.

The Atlantic's Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese Ingredients: Ciabatta Bread

Ciabatta is ciabatta. Yummy ciabatta is even better.

the grilled cheese:

the atlantic’s pea pesto grilled cheese: A

I am really glad that I made this grilled cheese as it is very unique. The Manchego cheese, which the non-melted version I had previously disliked, was great. The pea pesto had a very distinct taste (so distinct I can’t describe it) that I think everyone should try at least once. At this stage, this was not a grilled cheese I would think of personally, so I am very glad I stumbled on The Atlantic‘s article on peas.

ingredients were purchased at…

  • Whole Foods (Manchego Cheese, Pine Nuts, Sourdough Ciabatta)

1 thought on “The Atlantic’s Pea Pesto Grilled Cheese”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.