Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese

Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese

I have pushed the grilled cheese envelope before, with salmon, potato pancakes, quesadillas and bruschetta and am doing it again with pasta. My father recently purchased Ohio City Pasta and I have been trying to devise how to include said pasta within a grilled cheese. The problem with my thinking was that I was trying to include the pasta with bread (a lot of carbs), as opposed to using it as the bread. Now, I finally created a blue cheese recipe, that although it may not be a grilled cheese sandwich, was very tasty.


Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese: Parmesan Cheese

cheese #1: parmesan

Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese: Point Reyes Blue Cheese

cheese #2: point reyes farmstead blue cheese

I was thinking of what other cheeses to prepare with this very unique and quite possibly not grilled cheese when I first thought of Gruyere. Good choice, but one that I felt I had used too often. My next thought was blue cheese, which it appears, I have only used once. I was not going to include it directly in the “sandwich,” yet on the side in a cream sauce, similar to an Alfredo.

The cheesemonger at Whole Foods told me to bring the cheese to room temperature as it would melt better in the sauce. This is why the blue cheese looks like a melted glob of goodness…

Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese: Point Reyes Blue Cheese

The cheese production begins with the morning milking at about 2:00 am. Around 4:00 a.m., the fluid milk is pumped directly into stainless steel vats in the cheese production facility adjacent to the milking barn, guaranteeing a freshness that can’t be duplicated. Several natural ingredients are added to the Grade A, raw milk: cultures for flavor and to increase acidity, enzymes in order for the curd to form, kosher salt for flavor and mold (penicillium roqueforti) to create the blue veins in the cheese. When the milk reaches a specific pH level and the curd feels right (a combination of science and art), the curd is cut, the whey is drained from the curds and the curds are hooped (poured) into forms to make the wheels.

The following day the cheese is removed from the forms and taken to a curing room for about 3 weeks. In the curing room the wheels are hand-salted, turned numerous times by hand and punched with stainless steel needles to introduce oxygen into the body of the cheese. The oxygen is needed to activate the mold and create the blue veins found in Original Blue. The last step is the aging room. Here the wheels are left for 5-6 months. During this long aging process the creamy texture and full-flavors develop. (Point Reyes Cheese)

Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese: Ohio City Whole Wheat Pasta


Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese: Boiling the Pasta

Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese: Tossing the Pasta

After boiling the pasta for a few minutes, I tossed it in olive oil, salt, pepper, fresh/garden-grown rosemary/thyme, some Parmesan cheese and a small amount of chopped broccoli.

Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese: Blue Cheese Cream Sauce

I had wanted to go with a straight Alfredo sauce and include it within the grilled cheese, but since I did not want the pasta to be runny, I decided to create a “dipping sauce.” As I have never created a blue cheese sauce, I found a recipe for Alfredo sauce and replaced the Parmesan cheese with blue cheese. Simple enough…

The photos below demonstrate how to compile this pasta grilled cheese, in a baking dish, preferably rectangle (or square).

the grilled cheese:

(Ed. Note: I topped off the sandwich with leftover Parmesan cheese, as shown in melted form.)

blue cheese pasta grilled cheese: A

Yes, unfortunately, I know: this is not a grilled cheese, unless you are using a very liberal definition of “grilled cheese.” The idea stemmed from hoping to create a grilled cheese sandwich and instead succeeded in concocting something between a pasta dish and a pasta sandwich. On its own, the whole wheat pasta and blue cheese tasted delicious. The blue cheese sauce, although a bit overpowering, was a delicious addition and could be used in many a creation. I would say no matter how one categorizes this creation, it was a winner (especially since father loved it).

Taking photos of grilled cheese sandwiches, no matter how different and unique they are, does get old after awhile. This pasta-blue cheese-grilled-cheese-thing allowed me an escape to photograph a completely new food.

ingredients were purchased at…

3 thoughts on “Blue Cheese Pasta Grilled Cheese”

  • This might be my favorite grilled cheese yet! To actually “grill” it, mix the pasta & broccoli with some egg and let it set up over lowish heat in a cast iron skillet (kinda like a fritatta) until it’s golden. Flip it and do the same to the other side. Slice, dip in sauce, put in face:)

    • Thanks! Since this is your favorite grilled cheese, I must believe that you actually think it is a grilled cheese. Yay!

      Your frittata idea is perfect and something I will definitely have to try. My dad loved my version, so I am sure he wouldn’t mind trying an improved version. It will be interesting to compare the two.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.